Kim Minseun, PhD Student
Taras Shevchenko National University of Kyiv, Kyiv, Ukraine
DOI: https://doi.org/10.17721/1728-2640.2021.150.6
REVIEW GENRE IN THE SCIENTIFIC WORKS OF MARKO VARSHAVCHYK (1918-2001)
The scientific achievements of M. Ya. Varshavchyk have been studied, his review publications have been singled out and analyzed. It was found that during his scientific life the scientist published 18 reviews of new publications in historical source studies, archiving and special historical disciplines. Among the whole array of reviews, attention is focused on the review and analysis of his responses to works on theoretical source studies, problems of source practice, issues of methodology and methods of research, critique of sources and more. It is established that the scientific work of the scientist began with the publication of a review of a textbook on the theory and practice of archival work. Priority topics and leading topics that were of scientific interest to M. Ya. Varshavchyk were identified. Among them: the structure of historical source studies, the relationship between methodology and methods of source studies, historiography of source studies, quantitative methods in historical research, special disciplines and their place in historical source studies.
Particular attention is paid to reviews of collections of documents, archeographic publications, where there are full / selected texts of documents, their interpretation, dating, comments and notes, issues of textual analysis of the original text.
It is noted that, as a rule, reviews have been published in leading professional journals in historical sciences.
Key words: source studies, source theory, historiography, review, methodology, classification, critique of sources.
Submitted: 01.06.2021
Download Full Text
References:
1. Archives of Taras Shevchenko National University of Kyiv. Personnel File of M. Varshavchyk, PVS – 13, 101 sheets.
2. State Archive of Kyiv, fund 346, list 5, file 73, 18 sheets.
3. Central State Historical Archive of Ukraine in Kyiv, fund 2245-R, list. 3, file 103, 55 sheets.
4. Breha, H. (2003). Varshavchyk Mark Yakymovych. In V. Smolii (Ed.), Ukrainian Historians of the 20th century: Biobibliographical Catalog. Kyiv: [s. n.]. P. 44. [in Ukrainian]
5. Varshavchik, M. (1993). Review of: Special Historical Disciplines. A Handbook, by V. Zamlinskij et al. Kyiv: NMK VO, 1992. 324 p. Ukrainian Historical Journal, 3, 124-128. [in Russian]
6. Varshavchik, M. & Strel’skij, V. (1971). Review of: Source Study. Theoretic and Methodological Problems, by M. Smidt et al. Moscow: Science, 1969. 512 p. Ukrainian Historical Journal, 8, 139-140. [in Russian]
7. Varshavchik, M. (1947). Review of: Theory and Practice of Archiving. A Handbook, by K. Mityaev. Moscow, 1946. 248 p. Scientific and Imformation Bulletin of Archival Administration of Ukrainian SSR, 1, 41-42. [in Russian]
8. Varshavchik, M. & Butsko, N. (1977). Review of: Theory and Methodic of the Source Studies of the History of USSR. Kyiv: Higher School, 1976. 130 p. Archives of Ukraine, 1, 80-82. [in Russian]
9. Varshavchik, M. & Yakovlev, S. (1975). Subject, Method and Tasks of Archeography (on the new handbook). Review of: Theory and Methodology of Soviet Arheography. A Handbook, by M. Seleznyov. Moscow, 1974. 202 p. Soviet Archives, 4, 97-99. [in Russian]
10. Varshavchik, M. (1974). About the Book “Source Study of Native History”. Review of: Source Study of Native History. A Collection of Papers, Issue 1. Moscow, 1973. 396 p. Ukrainian Historical Journal, 7, 91-98. [in Russian]
11. Varshavchik, M. (1964). Glory Pages of Heroic Past. Review of: Sailors’ Struggle for the Soviet Rule over Ukraine (November 1917 – 1920). Collection of Documents, by V. Aleksandrov & T. fedorov. Kyiv: Academy of Sciences of USSR Publishing, 1963. 689 p. Communist of Ukraine, 2, 91-95. [in Ukrainian]
12. Danilevskij, A. (1920). Essay on Russian diplomacy of private acts. Lectures given to the students of the “Archival Courses” at the Petrograd Archaeological Institute in 1918. Petrograd: [s. n.]. [in Russian]
13. Source Study of Native History. Collection of Papers. (1973). Issue 1. Moscow: [s. n.]. [in Russian]
14. Shmidt, M. et al. (Eds.). (1969). Source Study. Theoretic and Methodological Problems. Moscow: Science. [in Russian]
15. Karakura, Ya. (1999). Structure of Historical Science: Theoretical and Methodological Aspect. In History of Archival Study: Memories, Research, Sources. Vol. 2: Special Branches of History: A Collection in Honor of M. Varshavchyk. Kyiv: [s. n.]. Pp. 18-25. [in Ukrainian]
16. Karakura, Ya. (2004). Varshavchyk Marko Yakymovych. In H. Kazmyrchuk (Ed.), Faculty of History of Taras Shevchenko national University of Kyiv: Past and Present (1834-2004). Kyiv: Prime-M. P. 166. [in Ukrainian]
17. Karakura, Ya. & Shcherbak, M. (2004). University Center for Historical Source, Archival Study and Historiography. Bulletin of Taras Shevchenko National University of Kyiv, 73, 17-25. [in Ukrainian]
18. Karakura, Ya. (2005). Varshavchyk Marko Yakymovych. In I. Dziuba (Ed.), Encyclopedia of Modern Ukraine. Vol. 4. Kyiv: [s. n.]. P. 95. [in Ukrainian]
19. Kovalskyi, M. (1999). Some Reflections on the Contribution of the Scientists of Kyiv University, Professors V. Strelskyi and M. Varshavchyk in the Development of Theoretical Source Studies. Issue 2: Special Branches of History: A Collection in Honor of M. Varshavchyk. Kyiv: [s. n.]. Pp. 95-99. [in Ukrainian]
20. Koval’chenko, I. (1969). On the Application of Mathematical and Statistical Methods in Historical Research. In Source Studies. Theoretical and Methodological Issues. Moscow: Science. Pp. 115-133. [in Russian]
21. Koroliov, B. (1999). Development of Problems of Theoretical Source Studies in the Works of M. Varshavchyk. In History of Archival Study: Memories, Research, Sources. Vol. 2: Special Branches of History: A Collection in Honor of M. Varshavchyk. Kyiv: [s. n.]. [in Ukrainian]
22. Koroliov, B. (1999). Pedagogue, Scientist, Person: A Word about Mark Varshavchyk. In History of Archival Study: Memories, Research, Sources. Vol. 2: Special Branches of History: A Collection in Honor of M. Varshavchyk. Kyiv: [s. n.]. [in Ukrainian]
23. Lytvak, B. (1969). On the Ways of Development of Source Study of Mass Sources. In Source Studies. Theoretical and Methodological Issues. Moscow: Science. Pp. 102-114. [in Russian]
24. Makovska, N. (2007). Varshavchyk Marko Yakymovych. In Ukrainian Archivists (19th – 20th century): Biobibliographical Catalog. Kyiv: State Committee of Archives of Ukraine. Pp. 92-94. [in Ukrainian]
25. Makovska, N. (2008). Varshavchyk Marko Yakymovych. In Ukrainian Archival Encyclopedia. Kyiv: State Committee of Archives of Ukraine. Pp. 198-199. [in Ukrainian]
26. Mayakovskij, I. (1920). Historical Essay of Archiving in Russia. Lectures Given to the Students of the Archive Courses. Petrograd: [s. n.]. [in Russian]
27. Pashuto, V. (1969). Some general Issues of Chronical Source Study. In Source Studies. Theoretical and Methodological Issues. Moscow: Science. Pp. 64-77. [in Russian]
28. Picheta, V. (1922). Introduction to Russian History (Sources and Historiography). Moscow: [s. n.]. [in Russian]
29. Voitsekhivska, I. (Ed.). (2018). Professor Marko Varshavchyk (to the 100th Anniversary of His Birth). Korsun-Shevchenkivskyi: Publisher I. Maidanchenko. [in Ukrainian]
30. Seleznyov, M. (1974). Theory and Methodology of Soviet Archeography. A Handbook. Moscow: [s. n.]. [in Russian]
31. Cherepnin, L. (1973). On the Issue of Methodology and Methodic of Source Studies and Special Branches of History. In Source Study of Native History. Collection of Papers. Issue 1. Moscow: Science. Pp. 32-63. [in Russian]
32. Shmidt, S. (1969). Modern Issues of Source Studies. In Source Studies. Theoretical and Methodological Issues. Moscow: Science. Pp. 7-58. [in Russian]
33. Shmorhun, P. (1998). Varshavchyk Marko Yakymovych (1918-2001). In Source Studies of the History of Ukraine. Kyiv: 1998. Pp. 157-158. [in Ukrainian]