T. Boriak, PhD in History, Doctoral Student

Taras Shevchenko National University of Kyiv, Kyiv, Ukraine

DOI: https://doi.org/10.17721/1728-2640.2020.147.1


MEMORIAL SIGNS TO VICTIMS OF 1932-1933 FAMINE IN RUSSIAN FEDERATION: REGIONAL, CHRONOLOGICAL AND IDEOLOGICAL LEVELS OF THE POLITICS OF MEMORY


The article analyzes official politics of memory of the Russian Federation regarding commemoration of famine victims from the beginning of 1930s. The research allows to get data of the Russian case that later can be compared with the data of the Ukrainian case. Analysis of politics of memory of the Russian state toward victims of the artificial famine has proven that Kuban’ is an unconditional leader among the Russian regions where memory about those events is still alive: about 20 of monuments have been revealed. To the contrary, only one village outside Kuban’ (i.e. other grain-producing regions of the Russian soviet republic) has one monument and one cross on a local cemetery. Such amount of memorial sites devoted to the victims of 1932-1933 famine contradicts thesis of the Russian historian V. Kondrashyn. He states that every Russian village still keeps memory about the given above famine. Therefore, the author tried to figure out what official politics of memory is behind creation of memorial space devoted to famine victims. Official politics of memory of the Russian state has put narrative on “the Great Victory” in the WWII in the foundation of contemporary state- and nation-building. The research has proven that this politics of memory influences articulation and reflections by the historians of 1930s events directly. On the other hand, narrative found in the informational space of the RF, indicates inability to break off with the soviet concept on history. This concept obviously has left no space for artificial famine organized by the top authorities. Finally, the research has proven that the researchers of local Kuban’ history realize marginal status in the RF of both famine victims commemoration and historical studies on the topic, as well as marginal and poor presence of the famine of 1932-1933 in collective memory of Russians. Still, despite this being the case, Russian historians reproach their Ukrainian colleagues for politicization of the topic and an attempt to commemorate their “dead” out of victims of the “common tragedy” of both “brotherhood” nations.

Keywords: famine of 1932–1933, monuments, historical memory, commemorative practices, Russian Federation, Kuban’.

Received by the editorial board: 15.12.20

Download Full Text

References:

1. Official Website of the Administration of the Shkurinskoe Rural Settlement of the Kushchevsky District of the Krasnodar Krai. URL: http://bit.ly/BKNUH147-1. [In Russian].

2. Mass Graves of farmstead Residents Who Died from Political Repression. In Monuments to Victims of Political Repression in the Territory of the Former USSR. Compiled by the Sakharov Center. URL: http://bit.ly/BKNUH147-2. [In Russian].

3. Burmistrov, A. (2017, May 10). In the Face of History. Volga Photo Website. URL: http://bit.ly/BKNUH147-3. [In Russian].

4. A Presentation of a Controversial Book about the “Genocide of the Cossacks” Took Place in Krasnodar. (2017, December 24). Red Star Informational Agency. URL: http://bit.ly/BKNUH147-4. [In Russian].

5. A Monument to Victims of a Famine May be Raised in Shchors Park. (2012, April 4). 63ru Internet Periodical. URL: http://bit.ly/BKNUH147-5. [In Russian].

6. Vladimirov, V. (2019, November 30). Golodomor in USSR: A Tragedy, Forgotten in Russia. Interview with Andrej Zubov. Voice of America. URL: http://bit.ly/BKNUH147-6. [In Russian].

7. Famine of 1932-1933 in Kuban. Field Materials of Kuban Folklore and Ethnographic Expedition of the of the Scientific Research Center for Traditional Culture “Kuban Cossack Chorus”. (2009). In N. Bondar’, O. Matveeva (Eds.), Proceedings of Scientific Practical Conference “Historical memory of the People of Southern Russia about Famine of 1932-1933”. Krasnodar: Plexanovec. Pp. 336-442. [In Russian].

8. Holodomor of 1932-1933 in Popovichevskaya Stanitsa. Website of Kalininskaya Stanitsa. URL: http://bit.ly/BKNUH147-7. [In Russian].

9. Gorelov, A. (n. d.). Pages of Bitter Memory. Otradnensky District Society of Historians and Archivists Named after Saint Nestor the Chronicler. URL: http://bit.ly/BKNUH147-8. [In Russian].

10. Gudz, V. (2019). Holodomor of 1932-1933 in Ukraine in the Russian Scientific Literature. In: V. Gudz, Historiography of Holodomor of 1932-1933 in Ukraine. Melіtopol: [s. n.]. Pp. 885-945. [In Ukrainian].

11. Dmitriev, S. (2013, November 29). Viktor Kondrashin: it’s a Shame that Russia Has no Policy to Perpetuate the Memory of the Innocent Victims. RFI. http://bit.ly/BKNUH147-9. [In Russian].

12. A Resident of Yejsk District Settled a Monument to Victims of the Holodomor. (2015, July 24). YugTimes. URL: https://yugtimes.com/news/11624/. [In Russian].

13. Denial of the Holodomor in Ukraine by Russian Historians. (n. d.). In Holodomor of 1932-1933 in Ukraine. Electronic Document Corpus (2004–). Institute of the History of Ukraine of the National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine. URL: http://resource.history.org.ua/project/0000006. [in Ukrainian].

14. “The Local Park will be Repaired by the Anniversary of the Village of Nadezhnaya, Otradnensky District”. (2020, September 30). Informational Portal “Kuban 24”. URL: http://bit.ly/BKNUH147-10. [In Russian].

15. Kasianov, H. (2010). Danse macabre: Famine of 1932–1933 in Politics, Mass Consciousness and Historiography (1980’s – Early 2000’s). Kyiv: Our Time. [In Ukrainian].

16. Kondrashin, V. (2008, April 4). Speech at the International Conference “Ukraine and Russia: History and Image of History”. Center for Ukrainian and Belarus Studies of the Faculty of History of the Moscow State University. URL: http://www.hist.msu.ru/Labs/UkrBel/obrukr-golod.htm. [In Russian].

17. Kondrashin, V. (2009). Famine of 1932-1933 – Common Tragedy of the Peoples of the Soviet Union. Bulletin of Penza State Pedagogical University. Humanities, 11(15), 118. URL: http://bit.ly/BKNUH147-11. [In Russian].

18. Kondrashin, V. (2004). Tragedy of 1932-1933 in the Villages of Volga Region: People’s Memory. Notes of the Local History Experts, 2(2), 83-100. [In Russian].

19. Krasnodar: Monuments and Statues. TripAdvisor LLC. URL: http://bit.ly/BKNUH147-12. [In Russian].

20. Soviet Kuban: from Decossackization to “Blacklisting”. (n. d.). URL: http://bit.ly/BKNUH147-13. [In Russian].

21. Kulchytskyi, S. (2021). Kondrashyn Vіktor Vіktorovych. In Encyclopedia of the History of Ukraine. Additional Volume 2. Kyiv: Institute of the History of Ukraine of the National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine. Preprint. [In Ukrainian].

22. Moscow Mayor's Office Agreed to Commemorate the Victims of Mass Famine in the USSR. (2019, November 28). Interfax. URL: https://www.interfax.ru/moscow/686004. [In Russian].

23. Museum and Memorial to Fritdtjof Nansen. (2017, October 11). Mega-Marx. URL: http://megamarx.ru/21935/. [In Russian].

24. Nadyozhnenskoe Rural Settlement. History of the Founding of Nadyozhnaya Stanitsa. Otradnaya.RU. URL: http://bit.ly/BKNUH147-14. [In Russian].

25. Nesterova, A. (2020, November 19). A Monument to the Victims of Political Repression, Hunger and Wars Was Unveiled Today in the Village of Sovkhoznoye. Kuban Star. URL: http://bit.ly/BKNUH147-15. [In Russian].

26. Monument to the Polar Explorer and Savior of the Starving Nansen Unveiled. (2017, October 17). SaratovBiznesKonsalting (SarBK). http://bit.ly/BKNUH147-16. [In Russian].

27. Otrado-Olginskoe Rural Settlement. Wikipedia. URL: http://bit.ly/BKNUH147-17. [In Russian].

28. Monument to the Victims of the Holodomor and Repression in the Village of Novoshcherbinovskaya. Presentation for the Lesson of Kuban Studies. On the 80th Anniversary of the Holodomor in the Kuban. (2013). URL: https://en.ppt-online.org/444110. [In Russian].

29. Monument to the Victims of the Holodomor and Repression: Krasnodar. In Monuments to Victims of Political Repression in the Territory of the Former USSR. Compiled by the Sakharov Center. URL: http://bit.ly/BKNUH147-18. [In Russian].

30. Monument to the Victims of the Repression and Holodomor. In Monuments to Victims of Political Repression in the Territory of the Former USSR. Compiled by the Sakharov Center. URL: http://bit.ly/BKNUH147-19. [In Russian].

31. Monument to Villagers Who Died from the Famine in 1933: Otradno-Olginskoe. In Monuments to Victims of Political Repression in the Territory of the Former USSR. Compiled by the Sakharov Center. URL: http://bit.ly/BKNUH147-20. [In Russian].

32. Monument to Villagers Who Died from the Famine in 1933: Malaya Serdoba. In Monuments to Victims of Political Repression in the Territory of the Former USSR. Compiled by the Sakharov Center. URL: http://bit.ly/BKNUH147-21. [In Russian].

33. The Memory of the Irklievites Who Died of Hunger Was Immortalized in the Cross. (2020, March 30). URL: http://bit.ly/BKNUH147-22. [In Russian].

34. The List of Cultural Heritage Objects (Historical and Cultural Monuments) Located on the Territory of the Krasnodar Krai: Appendix to the Law of August 17, 2000 No. 313-KZ "On the List of Cultural Heritage Objects (Historical and Cultural Monuments) Located in the Krasnodar Krai". PRAVO TECH. URL: http://bit.ly/BKNUH147-23. [In Russian].

35. Personal Website of Igor Smilevec. URL: http://smil.ucoz.ru/. [In Russian].

36. A Veneration Cross in Memory of the Victims of the Holodomor of 1932-1933 in the Zhuravskaya Stanitsa. Virtual Korenovsk. URL: http://bit.ly/BKNUH147-24. [In Russian].

37. [The Opening of a Monument]. (2014, April 4). Progorodsamara. http://bit.ly/BKNUH147-25. [In Russian].

38. [Fundraising]. (2014, January 29). Samara Web Journal “Drugoi Gorod”. https://drugoigorod.ru/nansenmonument/. [In Russian].

39. Rozhkov, A. (2009). “Mice ate People…”: Memory of the Famine of 1932-1933 in Responses to the Publications of I.I. Alekseenko. In N. Bondar’, O. Matveeva (Eds.), Proceedings of Scientific Practical Conference “Historical memory of the People of Southern Russia about Famine of 1932-1933”. Krasnodar: Plexanovec. Pp. 48-57.

40. Russia. List of Monuments and Commemorative Signs. In Monuments to Victims of Political Repression in the Territory of the Former USSR. Compiled by the Sakharov Center. URL: http://bit.ly/BKNUH147-26. [In Russian].

41. Sablina, T. (2018, March 22). Museum of Famine. LiveJournal. URL: http://bit.ly/BKNUH147-27. [In Russian].

42. Slaviansk on Kuban, Pobiedy Street, Monument to the Victims of Famine. All Housesof Russia. http://krasnodar.vsedomarossii.ru/house/41392. [In Russian].

43. Taranenko, A. (2010, November 24). The Secret famine of 1933. Open Letter to the President of the Russian Federation. textarchive.ru. URL: https://textarchive.ru/c-1508892-pall.html. [In Russian].

44. Taranenko, A. (2010, November 11). On the Revival of the Cossacks and the Historical Memory of the People. Personal Website of A. Taranenko. URL: http://alfetar.narod.ru/index/0-8. [In Russian].

45. Shilonosova, N. (2018, February 9). Hell in Heaven. How Thousands of People Starved and Died in the 1930’s in the Kuban. Yugopolis. https://www.yugopolis.ru/articles/ad-v-rayu-109508. [In Russian].

46. Yuzhakova, T. (2017, October 05). We Went to the “Well-fed” Land. Monument to Holodomor Victims Erected Behind Merekai Village. Perm krai. http://bit.ly/BKNUH147-28. [In Russian].

47. Kaminsky, A. (Hrsg.). Erinnerungsorte an den Holodomor 1932/33 in der Ukraine. Berlin: Leipziger Universitaetsverlag, 2008.

48. Koka-Lermont. (2017, March 23). An Interesting Fact in the Context of the Rapid Growth of Russian Patriotism. LiveJournal. http://bit.ly/BKNUH147-29. [In Russian].