Main

Issue 143 (2019)

S. Khalkhunov, PhD student

Central Ukrainian State Pedagogical University, Kropyvnytskyi, Ukraine

DOI: https://doi.org/10.17721/1728-2640.2019.143.8

CENTRAL COUNCIL'S MILITARY POLICY IN THE SOVIET HISTORIOGRAPHY OF THE 1920’s – 1980’s

The article examines the degree of studying the Ukrainian Central Council military policy by the Soviet historians from the beginning of 1917 to April 1918: considered the level of clarifying the issue about Ukrainianization Russian army military units, the creation of Ukrainian armed forces on Naddniprianschyna. The periodization was determined and the peculiarities of Soviet historiography formation on the topic under study were revealed.

According to the results of the study, in the majority of Soviet historians’ works, the question of the Ukrainianization of the Russian army military units was considered solely in the context of the revolutionization process of the Russian army military units. Volunteer Ukrainian regiments and free-wing detachments were assessed in the line of Soviet class-based methodology as "punitive", "bourgeois-nationalist" formations. There are no reliable figures on the number of Ukrainian troops. The uncritical use of the materials of the state archives, the Soviet and the party press necessitated the ignoring of historicism and objectivity principles.

At the same time it should be noted that even under the ideological scrutiny and political censorship of the 1920s and 1980s, Soviet researchers A. Likholat, S. Korolivsky, M. Rubach, N. Suprunenko, P. Garchev, A. Senderskyi, M. Yakupov, A. Tkachuk cited numerous facts in his writings that testified to the significant importance of the national component of the revolutionary processes, the significant influence of the national factor on the mass consciousness of soldiers and officers - Ukrainians.

Under these conditions the main reasons for the defeat of Ukrainian military policy become apparent: the Central Council failed to form capable regular units using the support of the soldiers in the first stage of the revolution; the delay in carrying out agrarian reform contributed to the growing influence of the Bolsheviks in the Ukrainian village; refusal to build a regular army had fatal consequences for Ukrainian statehood.

Keywords: Ukrainian Central Council, Soviet historiography, sources of research, military policy.

Received by the editorial board: 20.10.2019

Download Full Text

References:

1. Antonov-Ovseenko, V. (1924). Notes on the Civil War: in 4 volumes. Volume 1. Moscow: High Military Editorial Council. [In Russian].

2. Bosh, Ye. (1919). National Government and Soviet Power in Ukraine. Moscow: [s. n.]. [In Russian].

3. Bosh, Ye. (1925). Year of the Struggle. The Struggle for Power in Ukraine from April 1917 until the German Occupation. Moscow-Lenigrad: Gosizdat. [In Russian].

4. Harchev, P. (1969). Red Guard of Ukraine in the October Revolution. Kharkiv: [s. n.]. [In Ukrainian].

5. Hamretskyi, Yu. (1977). Soldiers in Ukraine in the Preparation and Carrying out of the Socialist Revolution. Ukrainian Historical Journal, 9, 127-136. [In Ukrainian].

6. Gamreckij, Yu. (1981). Bolshevization of the Soldier Masses of the Rear Garrisons of Ukraine in 1917. In I. Minc (Ed.), Revolutionary Movement in the Russian Army in 1917. Moscow: Science. [In Russian].

7. Golub, P. (1958). The Soldier Masses of the Southwestern Front in the Struggle for Power of the Soviets (March 1917 – February 1918)]. Kyiv: State Publishing of Political Literature of Ukrainian SSR. [In Russian].

8. Holubko, V. (1998). Army of the Ukrainian People's Republic 1917-1918. Creation and Struggle for State. Kyiv: Kalvaria. [In Ukrainian].

9. Horb, A. (1933). Red Guard of Katerynoslav (Dnepropetrovsk) in the Struggle for Power of the Soviets]. S. l.: [s. n.]. [In Ukrainian].

10. Deshchynskyi, L. (1982). Revolutionary Events in the Southwestern and Romanian Fronts, and the Black Sea Fleet in 1917]. Lviv: [s. n.]. [In Ukrainian].

11. Zatonskyi, V. (1929). From the Memoirs of the Ukrainian Revolution. Chronicle of Revolution, 4, 139-173. [In Ukrainian].

12. Ivanov, A. (1922). Central Council and the Kyiv Council in 1917-1918. Chronicle of Revolution, 2, 9-15. [In Russian].

13. Karpenko, H. (1931). Peasant Movement in the Kyiv Region during the Austro-German Occupation and the Hetmanate. Chronicle of Revolution, 1-2 (46-47), 67-92. [In Ukrainian].

14. Kviring, E. (1922). Yekaterinoslav Council and the October Revolution. Chronicle of Revolution, 1, 63-73. [In Russian].

15. Korolivskij, S. et al. (1967). Victory of Soviet Power in Ukraine. Moscow: Science. [In Russian].

16. Lapchynskyi, H. (1928). The Struggle for Kiev. January, 1918. Chronicle of Revolution, 2, 209-220. [In Ukrainian].

17. Lykholat, A. (1955). The Defeat of the Nationalist Counter-Revolution in Ukraine (1917-1922). Kiev: State Political Publishing. [In Ukrainian].

18. Manilov, V. (1923). From the History of Relations between the Central Council and the Provisional Government. Chronicle of Revolution, 1, 65-79. [In Ukrainian].

19. Miller, V. & Protasov, L. (1981). The Revolutionary Movement in the Army. In A. Alatorceva & V. Naumov, Soviet Historiography of the Great October Socialist Revolution. Moscow: Science. [In Russian].

20. Naumov, V. & Miller, V. (1981). On the Question of the Place of Researches of the History of Revolutionary Movement in the Army in 1917 in the Historiography of the Great October Revolution. In I. Minc (Ed.), Revolutionary Movement in the Russian Army in 1917. Moscow: Science. [In Russian].

21. Parkhomenkov, Yu. (2009). Soviet Historiography on Socio-political Processes in Ukraine in 1917 – Early 1918]. Science. Religion. Society, 2, 70-74. [In Ukrainian].

22. Petrovskij, G. (1922). Essays on the History of the October Revolution in Donbass Region. Chronicle of Revolution, 1, 58-62. [In Russian].

23. Pyrih, R. (2009). Memoirs of Contemporaries as a Source from the History of the Ukrainian Revolution of 1917-1921. History of the Ukrainian Revolution of 1917-1921 Research Problems, 4, 31-58. [In Ukrainian].

24. Pyrih. R. (2011). Sources from the History of the Ukrainian Revolution of 1917-1921: Materials of Personal Origin. Archives of Ukraine, 6, 83-102. [In Ukrainian].

25. Rubach, M. (1925). On the History of the Conflict between the Council of People's Commissars and the Central Council. Chronicle of Revolution, 2 (11), 53-58. [In Russian].

26. Rubach, M. (1957). Essays on the History of the Revolutionary Transformation of Agrarian Relations in Ukraine during the October Revolution. Kyiv: Academy of Sciences of Ukrainian SSR Publishing. [In Ukrainian].

27. Sednerskyi, A. (1957). October and January Armed Uprising in Kyiv (October 1917 – January 1918). Kyiv: [s. n.]. [In Ukrainian].

28. Smolnikov, A. (1984). Army of the Victorious Revolution (Soviet Historiography of the Bolshevization of the Army during the Preparation and Conduct of the Great October Socialist Revolution). Moscow: Thought. [In Russian].

29. Soldatenko, V. (1992). The Creation of the Ukrainian Statehood and the Problem of the Armed Forces, March – April 1918]. Ukrainian Historical Journal, 5, 38-51. [In Ukrainian].

30. Soldatenko, V. (1992). The Central Council and the Ukrainianization of the Army. Ukrainian Historical Journal, 6, 26-39. [In Ukrainian].

31. Strelskij, G. (1978). Memoirs as a Source of Study of the Great October in Ukraine. Kyiv: Higher School. [In Ukrainian].

32. Sukhyno-Khomenko, V. (1928). Concerning the Peculiarities of the Proletarian Revolution in Ukraine. Chronicle of Revolution, 4, 70-120. [In Ukrainian].

33. Tkachuk, A. (1967). The Collapse of the Central Rada's Attempts to Use Ukrainian Military Formations in 1917. Ukrainian Historical Journal, 8, 75-84. [In Ukrainian].

34. Shabatin, I. (1927). From the Overthrow of Tsar to the Power of Soviets. In 1917 – 1920 in Bila Tserkva Region. Bila Tserkva: [s. n.]. Pp. 6-22. [In Ukrainian].

35. Yurkovskyi, N. (1981). The Bolsheviks in the Struggle against Ukrainian Bourgeois Nationalism in the Black Sea Fleet: 1917-1918. In I. Minc (Ed.), Revolutionary Movement in the Russian Army in 1917. Moscow: Science. [In Russian].

36. Yakupov, N. (1975). The Struggle for the Army in 1917 (the Bolsheviks’ Activities in the Front-line Districts). Moscow: Thought. [In Russian].

37. Yakupov, N. (1980). The Bolsheviks in Charge of the Revolutionary Soldier Masses (1917 – January 1918). Moscow: Thought. [In Russian].